Buy or Rent Calculator
Compare renting with buying a similar home in Ontario: how your wealth could differ over your stay, the cash each needs, and how sensitive the answer is to your assumptions. For education only. This isn't financial, tax or mortgage advice, and it isn't a mortgage approval.
Step 1 of 4: The home
Only Ontario is supported for now, because its purchase taxes are calculated automatically.
Toronto adds its own land transfer tax on top of Ontario's.
Resale and owner-occupied only.
Today or later. Rules: ON-2026.04-r1, checked 2026-11-04.
How the Buy or Rent Calculator works
The calculator compares two households that start with the same savings. One buys a home; the other rents a similar one. Month by month, it tracks what each pays for housing, what each has left to invest, and what each would be worth if the home were sold at that point.
Each month, whichever option costs less leaves money over. The calculator assumes you invest a share of that difference (100% unless you change it) and spend the rest. That share matters a lot. Mortgage principal is forced saving, while a renter's lower costs only build wealth if the difference is actually invested.
The buyer's wealth is the home's value, minus the mortgage still owed, minus selling costs, plus any investments. The renter's wealth is their investments plus any deposits the landlord still holds. Results show the gap at the end of your stay, when one option first pulls ahead, the cash each needs up front and each month, and money spent that you don't get back.
Rules and assumptions it uses
The tool applies current Ontario and federal rules for the closing date you choose:
- Ontario land transfer tax, plus Toronto's municipal tax inside the city. First-time buyer refunds only apply once you confirm you qualify.
- The minimum down payment, and whether your mortgage needs default insurance. Under 20% down, the premium is added to the loan and Ontario's tax on it is paid in cash at closing.
- Canadian fixed-rate mortgage maths, with the rate compounded twice a year. At each renewal, the balance is re-amortized over the years left.
- Rent paid at the start of each month, with Ontario's usual last month's rent deposit used for your final month.
- No break penalty if you sell when a mortgage term ends.
It also simplifies. Investment returns are entered after tax and fees, as if gains were taxed every year, while selling your home is tax-free. That leans toward buying. FHSA and Home Buyers' Plan tax effects, biweekly payments and variable rates aren't modelled.
A worked example
The tool opens with example numbers: an $850,000 freehold home in Toronto, 10% down, a 4.29% five-year fixed rate over 30 years, and $3,400 a month to rent a similar home. Both households stay 10 years, with home prices rising 2% a year, investments earning 4% and no first-time buyer refunds claimed.
| Figure | Buying | Renting |
|---|---|---|
| Cash needed at the start | $118,085 | $8,550 |
| Housing cash in month 1 | $5,417 | $3,630 |
| Money spent you don't get back | $612,201 | $478,470 |
| Wealth at the end | $359,471 | $404,721 |
Because the down payment is under 20%, the loan is insured. A $25,245 premium is added, making the mortgage $790,245, with a monthly payment of $3,888.53. Renting ends up $45,249 ahead, because the renter invests the difference every month. Small changes move the result:
- Investing 70% of the monthly difference instead of 100% puts buying ahead by $27,450.
- Home prices rising 4% a year instead of 2% puts buying ahead by $166,776.
- Staying 25 years instead of 10 puts buying ahead by $157,486. Buying pulls ahead about halfway through year 15.
Frequently asked questions
Does this tell me whether to buy?
No. It shows how wealth could differ under the assumptions you enter. The what-if scenarios show how much the answer depends on them. It isn't financial advice or a mortgage approval.
Why does buying start so far behind?
On closing day, the buyer pays the down payment, land transfer tax and other costs, and selling right away would also cost commission. The gap usually narrows as the mortgage is paid down and the home gains value.
Why is the renter assumed to invest?
Both households have the same budget, so whichever option is cheaper leaves money over. If you would spend that money instead, lower the share invested and watch the result move toward buying.
Are first-time buyer refunds included?
Only if you tick every eligibility condition and choose to claim them. Ontario and Toronto decide eligibility separately, and we never assume you qualify.
Are my numbers saved?
No. Everything stays in your browser while the page is open and nothing is sent to a server. Reloading the page brings back the example.